Jonathan Franzen Had A Point

Evidently the other day Jonathan Franzen caused quite a stir on the interwebs when he said that he hated e-readers. You can read this Huffington Post article here to get the full story. I was reading some of the twitter ire and one thing became clear: people love their e-readers!

I went to my book club the other night and the topic of e-readers came up. I think out of the whole group (there are 8 of us) only 3 of us didn’t already have an e-reader. Of the three of us that didn’t have one, one wanted to get one. Only 2 of us were holding out against e-readers! And you can bet that we were treated to the full sales pitch.

Some of the things that I learned about e-readers:

1.       You can share your books. One person can purchase books on their account and then share them up to a certain amount of times, which admittedly is pretty cool.

2.       If something happens to your device, you won’t lose all your books.

3.       Libraries are all over the e-books thing.

But then there was the whole stance on reading in bed with a book vs. an e-reader.

Apparently, reading in bed is easier with an e-reader. You don’t have to deal with that whole pesky, sweat inducing page turning motion, you just press a button and voila, new page. Since an e-reader is so light, you are also freed of having to expend energy holding up a heavy book.

I’ve heard a lot of really messed up reasons for running out and getting an e-reader. My favourite has to be the glare from the sun that makes it hard to read paper and ink. Or how you get sunscreen all over proper books which makes them grungy. Because I’m sure that your sunscreeny fingers actually polish your e-reader and the sun’s glare magically turns to a fine water mist to cool you off when you read something on an e-reader.

I will concede that the idea of traveling with 10 books on an e-reader appeals to me more than lugging 10 books around the world with me. But since I don’t travel that often these days, I’m more than content to keep carrying one or 2 volumes with me.

Because at the end of the day, my Agatha Christie volume will never malfunction on me on a long, cold bus ride home. I will not have to open and close my well worn copy of Pride and Prejudice because my page has frozen. I can tuck my soaking wet umbrella next to my Game of Thrones and the worst that will happen is some water damage, that will dry and leave the pages delightfully crinkly.

Also? At the end of my long work day I like to look around the bus and see what other people are reading! It brings out some weird feeling of bus camaraderie that I don’t normally feel. It can be an excellent breeding ground for new read ideas or it can make me smile when I see someone else evidently enjoying one of my favourites.

An e-reader may seduce you with its crisp design or the many sleek case options that show case your personality. But can you stack your e-readers in all manner of delightful configurations? Can your e-reader be passed along to your children or grandchildren to ensure future generations of readers can enjoy the miracle of Harry Potter and Anne of Green Gables? Do e-readers give off that  most intoxicating old book smell?

Exactly. Which is why this reader will not be indulging in anything more than the time tested and true paper, ink and binding.


2 thoughts on “Jonathan Franzen Had A Point

  1. And here I thought I was the last ereader hold out. There’s something about holding a book, turning the pages, smelling the ink that makes me firmly in the book camp. And crinkly pages? Awesomeness.

  2. Pingback: Coming around to the idea of an E-Reader…for other people | The Paperback Princess

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s