Giving Daisy Goodwin Another Shot

Recently The Socratic Salon hosted a discussion about what it takes for readers to go back to authors who have burned them before. It was an interesting and lively discussion about the ways that we make room for or dismiss authors who have maybe disappointed our hopes in the past.

The first time I read Daisy Goodwin, I was disappointed. In The American Heiress, I was expecting a Downton Abbey worthy story featuring a fabulously wealthy American who comes to Britain intent on snagging a titled young man to marry. And that is the bare bones story but it never really gelled with me. I remember being disappointed that there wasn’t more substance to the story. I’m not sure if I had hoped that she would marry for love or find that a title wasn’t what it was cracked up to be. I’m always annoyed when characters move to other worlds and just expect to be able to do whatever they wanted. I remember being disappointed, though, that the main character lacked any kind of spunk.

But when I saw The Fortune Hunter, and read that it featured the love triangle between Elisabeth of Austria, Bay Middleton, and Middleton’s fiancee Charlotte Baird, well I was immediately willing to forgive Goodwin her past transgressions against me.


If you’ve ever been to Vienna, you’re probably familiar with Elisabeth of Austria because of all the places that her portrait, the one of the young woman in the white ballgown with diamond stars in her abundant hair, is featured. When I went to Vienna and kept seeing the Winterhalter portrait, I was so entranced that I needed to know more about the woman. I found and purchased the Brigitte Hauman biography of Sisi (a book that Goodwin mentioned in her Afterword as being the best written about Sisi).

So I was somewhat familiar with the story. But there’s something so different about reading a biography of a person and having them brought to life by a fictional account.

The Fortune Hunter is a delight. It is the perfect kind of historical fiction novel that hits all the right notes. It manages to find the right balance of expressions that are right for the time without being heavy handed and phoney sounding. I thought Goodwin did an amazing job bringing Elisabeth to life as well as addressing her relationship with Bay Middleton. It’s not ever been proven whether their relationship was romantic and physical, although most tend to agree that it probably was. Charlotte Baird, the heiress to an immense fortune who Middleton did eventually marry, is the kind of heroine I can totally get behind. She doesn’t spend her time getting ready for parties and gossiping, she has an interest in photography and a disdain for the types of women who only think about The Season and getting married, as exemplified in her sister-in-law to be, Augusta.

fortune hunterOh no I thoroughly enjoyed this novel and am glad that my previous experience with Daisy Goodwin didn’t prevent me from wading into this one whole-heartedly. In the same Afterword, Goodwin mentions that she so enjoyed writing the scenes that feature Queen Victoria (and I can see why, they were hilarious) that she has become a main character for her next novel. She also mentioned that the new biography of Queen Victoria by A.N. Wilson was one of the best biographies written about her. A biography I just so happen have sitting on my table.

13 thoughts on “Giving Daisy Goodwin Another Shot

  1. How fun! I’m glad that you didn’t let one disappointing experience deter you. I wasn’t that happy with The American Heiress either and thus wasn’t sure I wanted to read The Fortune Hunter. But now I am having second thoughts… (I hope that Toni Morrison will fare similarly; Beloved is a tour de force!)

    • Beloved is still definitely on my list!
      I’m glad to have been your guinea pig in this case. And even gladder that it worked out for me! I had read so much historical fiction and was starting to fear that it was all the same and maybe I couldn’t enjoy it anymore? But first The Secret Book of Grazia dei Rossi and now The Fortune Hunter have reminded me what it’s like when this genre is gooooood.

  2. I love fictionalized accounts of real people. I get to learn about history and read fiction at the same time – what could be better? Sometimes it’s hard to find ones that are well done. This one sounds good! Was it easy to know what was fact and what was fiction? I loved that Beth Powning spelled it out for us at the end of her book, A Measure of Light.

    • Goodwin does the same thing at the end of the book. There’s actually a shortened biography of Elisabeth of Austria’s entire life – including her tragic death. She’s a historical figure that has featured in passing in this genre but has never been the star and she should be the star more often.

  3. I really have been wanting to read this one so I’m so glad you enjoyed it. For some reason The American Heiress was never one that I wanted to try- and now I feel validated in that as well!

  4. I’ve seen the cover of The Fortune Hunter everywhere, but had no idea what the story was until I read your review. It sounds very interesting. I love how you already had an interest in Elisabeth of Austria because of the portrait from Vienna like you were meant to read this book.

  5. This whole thing is nuts! I’ve loved both of these novels by Daisy Goodwin and am so anxious to read more!! Go, Daisy! You are an awesome author!!

    • I really wanted to like The American Heiress – it was actually a book that my book club chose to read and discuss. Once we’d read it we unanimously decided to read and discuss something else. There just didn’t seem like there was enough to actually talk about! I love the whole dollar princesses thing, I’m completely fascinated by the entire era and have read a lot about personalities of the time so I’m pretty familiar with them. It should have been everything I want in a book. But it just was not. I’m so glad, though, that The Fortune Hunter was so wonderful. It completely redeemed Goodwin for me and I’m really looking forward to whatever she has planned next. Especially if it features Queen Victoria!

  6. Pingback: Living Up To Bookish Expectations | The Paperback Princess

  7. Pingback: Lake Reads: Canadian Thanksgiving edition | The Paperback Princess

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s