A Roaring Success

“Have you read Z: A novel?”

This from my friend who had just read and loved it. I told her that no I hadn’t read it and actually didn’t plan on reading it because I just don’t like reading books set in the 1920s and don’t have the same romantic view of the Lost Generation. Really, if I read one more book about the wife of someone famous where she’s just this worshipping appendage, I will scream.

My friend ignored all of this and forced her copy of the book into my hands.

Because I am a peculiar kind of creature who is unable to return the munificence of a leant-book unread, I read it.

And I loved it.

I’d always felt sorry for Zelda Fitzgerald, thought she was a bit of a pathetic figure. Therese Anne Fowler showed me Zelda in a completely different way and now I’m kind of a fan.


Zelda Sayre was born in Montgomery, Alabama, the youngest child in a well-known family. Her father was a judge and the expectation was that Zelda would marry well and be the kind of young lady her family would be proud of.

Zelda had other plans. She relished being born at a time when women were starting to be able to do things for themselves, she wanted to run around town with shorter hemlines, leaving her corset at home. When she meets Scott Fitzgerald, it changes her whole life.

The story of Scott and Zelda Fitzgerald has been the fodder for stories for nearly 100 years. What I appreciated about this version was that Zelda was her own, complete person. She is trying to figure out where she fits into this life that Scott has created. She suffers from health problems that make it impossible for her to have more children after their daughter, Scottie, and her husband gets angry with her that she’s not giving him sons.

As Scott gets more famous and struggles with his own identity, with his desire to make a mark on the literary world, crippled with a desire to be a part of the class of people that has more money than they know what to do with, Zelda is left to pick up the pieces. But she refuses to just be a good little wife after a while. After she tires of the constant parties, after the drinking wreaks havoc on her system, she looks to find other ways of spending her time.

She writes and paints and dances but is never taken seriously as a writer, artist or dancer by her husband. She, who has followed Scott across continents and oceans based on what’s best for his career, is relegated to the role of wife and mother in his eyes. It’s no wonder Zelda ended up hospitalized – Scott was enough to drive anyone to mental exhaustion.

Oh yes, I loved this book. I loved the meditation on marriage and womanhood that Zelda offers in a time when women are just starting to be allowed to think of themselves as people. I loved Zelda’s unwillingness to settle for the kind of life her parents saw for her. Mostly I appreciated this new perspective on a woman I’ve long thought of as the patron saint of pathetic literary wives.

I am firmly Team Zelda.

18 thoughts on “A Roaring Success

  1. I wasn’t going to read it for the reasons you mentioned but your enraptured review tempts me. I reading THREE books concurrently though with one on the nightstand and two ILLs awaiting!

  2. I love this review, Eva! I’ve had this book on my list for a long time, but for some of the same reasons as you, it just didn’t seem urgent, even though I’d heard good things. But, you have renewed my interest in it, so I’ll be bumping it back up the list. Gonna go see if it’s even on my Goodreads shelf…

  3. I loved this book, too! But then I’ve always been intrigued by Zelda Fitzgerald. I’d love to read some of the stuff she wrote someday, see how it compares to her husband’s writing. I just wish she had a happier end to her life.

  4. This is a book that’s been on my TBR list for a while, and I’ve noticed it’s gotten mixed reviews. I think what people mistake with this book is that it’s not a biography by any sense but a fictionalization based on the lives of two well-known individuals. There are going to be discrepancies; it’s only natural!

    Also– Amazon Prime Video is creating a show based on Zelda Fitzgerald, called “Z: The Beginning of Everything.” Right now it’s just the pilot and then hopefully with enough votes, it’ll be the next Prime Video streaming show!

    • I don’t think we have access to Amazon anything up here in Canada. But if it does end up more mainstream, I’m going to have to check that out!
      It’s not a biography but when historical fiction like this is done well, you feel like you are getting to know the real person. I guess if you are a fan of Fitzgerald’s and think you know everything about him, you’re not going to love a book that doesn’t paint him in the most flattering light! But if half of it’s true, Zelda deserves a chance to finally get to tell her side of the story.

  5. I preordered this book a month or so before it was published, so there’s a post on my blog somewhere. I agree, I loved it. I’d always thought Zelda was a quack who ruined Fitzgerald’s opportunities. This book totally changed my mind and put me firmly on Team Zelda as well. I feel she had as much talent as Fitzgerald and he stifled her, from jealousy or power, who knows? Ironically, their weird mix reminds me of Gatsby and Daisy.

    • I remember you posting about this book. And even though you loved it, at the time I was thinking “yeah, yeah, another Jazz Age book, got it. Not for me.” I was super wrong.
      It seems like a lot of his work was based off his life and the lives of his “friends” so it’s not weird that the dynamic of him and Zelda should remind you of Gatsby and Daisy. Fitzgerald and Gatsy were both so obsessed with having enough money, with being a part of a different class. Must have been exhausting.

  6. Pingback: Badass Women: Flappers | The Paperback Princess

  7. Pingback: Hemingway as a footnote: Love and Ruin | The Paperback Princess

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s